Business Growth
How to Manage an Underperforming Salesperson (Steps, Questions, and Improvement Plan)
How to manage an underperforming salesperson in a small business: how to tell a slow month from a real performance problem, how to find the cause, the conversation to have, how to write a sales performance improvement plan, a template, a worked example, mistakes to avoid, and a Claude workflow for sales managers.

AI Educator, AI Tools and Training Club · November 17, 2026 · 8 min read

The short version
- To manage an underperforming salesperson, first confirm it is a real pattern and not one bad month, then find the cause in the activity, pipeline, and conversion numbers before you have the conversation.
- Most underperformance comes from one of a few places: not enough activity, the wrong activity, a skill gap, an unfair target or territory, or a motivation or fit problem. Each needs a different fix.
- If coaching does not move the numbers, put the agreed changes into a short written improvement plan with clear targets, support, and a review date, so both of you know exactly what success looks like.
How do you manage an underperforming salesperson?
To manage an underperforming salesperson, start with the numbers, not the person. Check whether the shortfall is a pattern over several months, then trace it through the funnel: how much activity they are doing, how much pipeline it creates, and how much of that pipeline they win. That tells you whether the problem is effort, skill, or something outside their control. Then talk to them privately, share what you found, ask for their view, and agree on two or three specific changes with weekly check-ins. If those changes do not move the numbers, formalize them in a written improvement plan with a clear end date.
My strong opinion: most underperformance in small sales teams is a management problem before it is a people problem. The rep was hired without a clear profile, onboarded in a week, given a target pulled from a revenue goal, and left alone until the quarter ended badly. Check your side of the table first. You will be fairer, and you will often find the fix there.
Is it a slow month or a real performance problem?
Sales results swing. One big deal slipping a week can make a good month look bad. Before you act, check these four things.
- Duration. Is it one month, or a pattern across a full sales cycle or more?
- Comparison. How do they compare with others who have similar territories, lead sources, and tenure? If the whole team is down, it is not an individual problem.
- Leading indicators. Are activity and new pipeline also down, or is it only closed revenue? Healthy activity with weak results this month often recovers on its own.
- Context. Has anything changed: a new product, a price rise, a lost lead source, a personal event? Ask before assuming.
Find the cause before you have the conversation
Walk down the funnel with their numbers. The first place their results drop away from the team's is usually where the problem lives.
| Cause | What the numbers show | Likely fix |
|---|---|---|
| Not enough activity | Fewer calls, emails, or meetings than peers | Agree daily or weekly activity minimums and protect time for prospecting |
| Wrong activity | Plenty of activity, little qualified pipeline | Tighten who they target and how they qualify |
| Skill gap | Good pipeline, low win rate at a specific stage | Coach on that stage: discovery, demos, objections, or closing |
| Unfair target or territory | Effort and skill look fine, the target was never realistic | Rebuild the quota from the territory's real potential |
| Motivation or fit | Numbers falling across the board, low engagement | Honest conversation about what has changed and whether the role still fits |
Common causes of sales underperformance and what fixes each
Questions to ask an underperforming salesperson
Open by sharing the facts you found, then listen more than you talk. These questions get to the cause without putting the rep on trial.
- Looking at these numbers, what do you think is going on?
- Which part of the sales process feels hardest for you right now?
- Walk me through your last two lost deals. Where did they go quiet?
- How is your week actually spent? What gets in the way of selling time?
- Is there anything about the target, the leads, or the product that feels unfair or unclear?
- What support would make the biggest difference over the next month?
- Is anything outside work affecting you that I should know about?
How to manage an underperforming salesperson step by step
- Confirm the pattern. Check duration, peers, leading indicators, and context so you are acting on a trend, not a bad week.
- Diagnose with the funnel. Find the stage where their numbers drop away from the team's.
- Have a private, direct conversation. Share the facts, ask for their view, and agree on what the problem is before you discuss fixes.
- Agree on two or three specific changes. For example, a minimum number of first meetings a week, a new discovery question set, or reviewing every proposal with you before it goes out.
- Coach weekly for a set period. Use your one-to-ones and pipeline reviews to check progress on the agreed changes, not just on revenue.
- Formalize it if needed. If the changes are not happening or not working, write them into an improvement plan with targets, support, and a review date.
- Make the call at the review date. Recognize the improvement and close the plan, extend it once if there is clear progress, or move to a different role or an exit.
How to write a sales performance improvement plan
A performance improvement plan is a short written agreement that sets out what needs to change, how it will be measured, what support the business will give, and by when. Written honestly, it is a real chance to succeed, not paperwork to justify a decision already made. If you have already decided to let someone go, a plan is unfair to them and wastes both your time.
| Section | What to write |
|---|---|
| The gap | The specific results and behaviors that are below expectations, with the numbers |
| Targets | Two to four measurable goals, mixing activity and results, for example meetings booked, pipeline created, and deals closed |
| Support | What the business will provide: coaching sessions, call reviews, leads, training, tools |
| Check-ins | Weekly meeting day and time, and what will be reviewed each week |
| Duration | A fixed period, long enough for the agreed changes to show up given your sales cycle, with a firm end date |
| Outcome | What happens if the targets are met, and what happens if they are not |
| Signatures | Both of you sign and date it, and each keeps a copy |
Sales performance improvement plan template
Example: managing an underperforming salesperson
Here is an illustrative example for a made-up commercial cleaning company with three salespeople. One rep, eight months in, has hit about half of their target for three months running while the other two are close to target.
| Metric | Struggling rep | Team average of other two reps |
|---|---|---|
| Outreach attempts | 260 | 240 |
| First meetings booked | 18 | 16 |
| Site walkthroughs completed | 6 | 10 |
| Proposals sent | 5 | 8 |
| Contracts won | 1 | 3 |
Illustrative monthly averages over the last quarter
Activity is not the problem. They outwork the others at the top of the funnel and book slightly more first meetings. The drop happens between the first meeting and the site walkthrough. In the conversation, the rep says many prospects "want to think about it" after the first call. Listening to two recorded calls confirms why: the rep pitches pricing in the first meeting before understanding the building, the cleaning schedule, or what is wrong with the current provider. The plan is narrow: use the team's discovery question set on every first meeting, never quote on the first call, and aim to book the walkthrough before the meeting ends. Weekly targets focus on walkthroughs booked, not revenue, because revenue lags. If walkthroughs rise toward the team level within six weeks, contracts should follow.
Mistakes to avoid when managing underperformance
- Waiting too long. A quiet problem in month one becomes a hard conversation in month six. Raise it as soon as the pattern is clear.
- Making it about revenue only. Revenue is the result. Coach the activity and stage numbers that lead to it.
- Giving vague feedback. "You need to step it up" gives the rep nothing to do. Name the stage, the behavior, and the number.
- Ignoring your own part. Check the target, the leads, the onboarding, and the coaching they actually received.
- Using a plan as a formality. If the outcome is already decided, be honest about it instead.
- Discussing it in front of the team. Performance conversations are always private.
How this fits with the rest of sales management
- To run the weekly coaching that turns the plan into progress: use How to Coach a Salesperson (A Weekly Sales Coaching System, Questions, and Template).
- To check the target was fair in the first place: see How to Set Sales Quotas (Methods, Examples, and Template).
- To track the plan deal by deal: fold it into How to Run a Pipeline Review (Questions, Template, and Steps).
- To prevent the problem in the next hire: start strong with How to Onboard a New Salesperson (30-60-90 Day Plan, Checklist, and Template).
How to manage an underperforming salesperson with Claude
The diagnosis is mostly comparison and arithmetic, and the conversation benefits from preparation. Claude helps with both. Open the Claude desktop app and work through it in passes.
- Export three to six months of activity, pipeline, and win data for the whole team from your CRM. Ask Claude to compare the struggling rep with the others at every stage of the funnel and to point out where the gap first opens.
- Paste in call notes or transcripts from a few of their recent sales calls and ask what patterns it sees at the stage where the numbers drop.
- Ask it to draft talking points for the conversation: the facts to share, the open questions to ask, and phrasing that stays on behavior and numbers rather than personality.
- After the conversation, give it your notes and ask for a draft improvement plan using the template above, with targets based on the team's own numbers.
- Review every line before you share it. Claude prepares the analysis and the draft, but the judgment about your person, and the conversation itself, stays with you.
Frequently asked questions
How do you tell if a salesperson is underperforming?
Look for a pattern over at least a full sales cycle, compare them with peers who have similar territories and leads, and check leading indicators like activity and new pipeline, not just closed revenue. One bad month is not a pattern.
What causes sales underperformance?
The usual causes are not enough activity, the wrong activity, a skill gap at a specific stage of the sales process, an unrealistic target or weak territory, or a motivation or fit problem. Each one needs a different fix.
What should be in a sales performance improvement plan?
The specific gap with numbers, two to four measurable targets, the support the business will give, weekly check-ins, a fixed duration, and what happens at the end if the targets are or are not met. Both people should sign it.
How long should a sales improvement plan last?
Long enough for the agreed changes to show up in the numbers given the length of your sales cycle, with weekly check-ins and a firm end date. Activity targets show progress sooner than revenue does, so a shorter sales cycle allows a shorter plan.
When should you let an underperforming salesperson go?
When the cause has been diagnosed, the rep has had clear targets, real support, and a fair amount of time, and the numbers still have not moved. Check the employment rules that apply to you before ending someone's employment.
How do you talk to a salesperson about poor performance?
Privately and directly. Share the specific numbers, ask what they think is going on, listen, agree on what the problem is, and then agree on a small number of concrete changes with a date to review progress.